Sunday, November 15, 2026

U.S. foreign policy fails


U.S. foreign policy fails

Two cases: Canada, Israel

 

Gordon L. Weil

Unless you sit in the White House, it’s impossible to ignore the loss of American influence in the world under the presidency of Donald Trump.

His core foreign policy precept is America First.  This is not simple isolationism.   More importantly, it means that the U.S. should be recognized as the world’s military and economic power and that other nations should follow its lead. 

The dominant framework for this thinking is economic.  The U.S. trade deficit shows it has suffered exploitation and must right the balance, partly using protective tariffs to aid American production.   Superior U.S. military force will drive others to negotiate on Trump’s terms or they will be damaged to the point of surrender.  Add to that, Trump’s overarching personal ambition.

Before Trump, American power had brought the U.S. respect and trust, if not affection.  His erratic, preemptive and unrealistic policies have undermined those assets. His reelection sent a signal to others that restoration of a more stable and reliable American ally was not to be counted on, now or ever. 

The effect of the misuse of American power in U.S. relations with other countries can be seen in the failure of U.S. ties with two of its closest and most dependent allies – Canada and Israel.

Trump’s view of Canada was determined by what he believed was the injustice of an unfavorable trade balance and his accurate perception that Canada existed in a weakened political condition, especially its military.  Though it was a big step to his ultimate goal, he thought that a tough trade policy would make Canada ripe for collapse and takeover as the 51st state.

The Liberal government was set for a massive electoral defeat at the hands of the Conservatives, a party favorable to American interests. In trade and economic terms, Canada was functionally almost the equivalent of being a state. 

But Trump blew it.  His call for the 51st state and the imposition of unjustified tariffs did not destroy Canada; it unified the sometimes fractious nation.  Conservatives did not become U.S. allies; many became patriotic Canadians.  The Liberals found a candidate for prime minister who had the background and skill to stand up to Trump, and they won.

Prime Minister Mark Carney imposed tariffs on the U.S., the only country beyond China to retaliate directly.  He broke off trade talks with the U.S. when faced with take-it-or-leave-it demands and insults to his nation.  Most importantly, he began aggressively diversifying Canada’s economic and military relations, permanently putting space between the two countries.

Instead of cultivating a relationship that could be made more favorable to the U.S., Trump bullied its closest ally into rejecting it.  Canada’s adjustment will be painful.  America’s loss will be costly.  Both will happen.

If American problems with Canada were the results of the sins of omission, its problems with Israel result from the sins of commission.

The U.S. has a tradition of strong, bipartisan support for Israel, dating from its founding in 1947.  As in other countries, Americans felt that support for the new Jewish state, an almost unique example of democracy in the Middle East, would somewhat compensate for help withheld during the Holocaust, when millions of European Jews were killed.

Support for Israel’s existence has been linked to support for its government, which expected unquestioning backing.  Sensing that such support would come more rapidly from the Republicans than from the Democrats, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu sought close ties to the GOP, which in turn gained the votes of many Jews and evangelical Christians.

Trump provided vetoes for Israel at the UN and military aid for its campaigns against neighboring Arabs and those in occupied areas, some of whom were terrorists.  Sensing he has a committed ally, Netanyahu led Trump into replacing peace efforts with Iran by an effort to take control of it.  The U.S. also ignored Israel’s killing of innocent Palestinians.

With Trump’s support, Netanyahu overreached.  Iran did not fall, and Israel was ostracized for its attacks on Palestinians.  A gap began to grow between congressional views on Middle East policy and Israel’s needs and desires.  The Iran war and reduced support for Israel affected the U.S. midterm results.  Trump has announced a major cutback in historic military aid to Israel.

Setbacks in relations with Canada and Israel resulted from Trump ignoring history and good advice and acting in the belief in his superiority.  They were part of his pattern.

He tried to swipe Greenland from its inhabitants and Denmark.  He condemned Europe for not aiding the U.S. in its Iran war, though he did not consult with it and tried to override its concerns about the Ukraine.  His style and language show little respect for others.

Other counties might view the midterms with relief, but must worry about what comes next.

 

  

Friday, November 13, 2026

Trump defeat slows right-wing surge


Trump defeat slows right-wing surge

Youth becomes a political force

 

Gordon L. Weil

By the start of the year, panic colored political commentary.  The Trump presidency was becoming the model for other nations moving to create right-wing governments.  He had legitimized and made respectable a shift toward conservative populism.

Wins by AfD, a right-wing party urging Germany to get over its Nazi guilt, and the unpopularity of the country’s leader were signs that the right was climbing.  If MAGA worked so well in the U.S., its appeal could be exported; Vice President JD Vance held an unprecedented meeting with the AfD leaders.

After the German state elections, forecasts of coming right-wing election wins have extended to France, Brazil and other countries almost as a foregone conclusion.  On the eve of Hungary’s presidential election, Vance travelled to Budapest to extend MAGA’s embrace to the country’s right-wing leader.

The expected right-wing wave faltered.  Trump’s America had been the leader in this political change, setting a pattern for many other countries, but it has suddenly become the follower as other countries rejected the American model.  This rejection has been sweeping the world, making it doubtful if the right will prevail in France or Germany.

In Hungary, Prime Minister Viktor Orbán had been the hope of the right. He had turned his country into the major irritant within NATO and the EU, and he drew closer to Russia, despite its aggression against Ukraine.  He was brought to the U.S. as a cheerleader for American conservatives. 

After the elections, Orbán and his party were out, replaced by Peter Magyar.  The new prime minister immediately reversed right-wing policies and restored his nation’s ties to regional organizations.

In Serbia, President Aleksander Vučič, head of the right-wing governing party, decided to try a move to become prime minister through an early election.  He lost to the Student List, the opposition that developed in just a few months, even without a leader.   Serbia’s change paralleled what had happened earlier in Hungary.

In Brazil, the right tried to restore the rule of Javier Bolsonaro, a president imprisoned for election tampering.  His son, Jair, openly favored by Trump, was defeated as was his father by the venerable liberal Lula da Silva.  Facing his own criminal charges, the younger Bolsonaro fled to the U.S. and was admitted by the Trump administration.

In India, the Cockroach movement, led by discontented students, has taken on the regime of the increasingly authoritarian Prime Minister Narendra Modi.  Street demonstrations have weakened Modi’s hold on power.

In France, where a presidential election will be held next year, Marine LePen has been seen as the hope of the right.  But once again, it was opposition started by students that has made the election outcome less predictable.

In Britain, the center-left Labour Party government gave way to new party leadership that has seemed poised to move more to the left. 

As quickly as conservative populism had arisen, it began to lose favor.  Opposition, especially by young people, challenged it.  Conservatism had owed much of its popularity to Trump’s success. Then, the Republican right-wing suffered a stunning defeat in the midterm elections.  The U.S. rejected right-wing conservatism just as others had.  It is no longer the beacon for change.

In the U.S., only the vestiges of MAGA and a weakened president remain with any power.   Trump’s moves from tariffs to his profiting from the presidency to the costs of the Iran war brought out a coalition that reversed the trend toward authoritarianism. 

It had seemed that everything had to get worse before it got better.  Finally, that happened.

A common theme has been evident as the right-wing losses have mounted: the Iran war was a devastating mistake.  The extreme right had opposed war, and Trump promised to avoid it.  Then, he chose to launch the Iran war.  There was no quick victory and, even worse, it drove up prices everywhere in the world without any prospect of when they might again be affordable.

Trump’s massive error not only took down the Republican Congress but contributed to the defeat of his allies elsewhere.  They had cozied up to Trump, believing he represented the future, but they paid the ultimate political price for their loyalty.  His mistake became their mistake.

In one major way, as his friends went to defeat, they offered him something positive. The U.S. had geared up for legal wars over supposed voter fraud.  But from Hungary to Brazil, leaders accepted, often gracefully, their defeat. 

Trump accepted the GOP defeat without that expected war, but not without grumbling.  In Israel, Prime Minister Netanyahu missed the message and reflexively charged voting irregularities in Arab areas, but his claims were promptly rejected by the official election commission. 

Right-wing populism may not have been delivered a fatal blow this year, but political events culminating in the midterms, slowed its surge on the world scene.

To readers:

Last week I noted that Susan Collins had served six terms.  That was incorrect; she will have served five terms.

Another note on Collins.  Watch how she votes between now and the end of her term in January. She can now afford to show her moderate side and resist Trump at times or she can reveal that the voters correctly concluded she had shed her moderation. 

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Why Sen. Susan Collins lost: the demise of a moderate


Why Susan Collins lost

The demise of a moderate

 

Gordon L. Weil

In 1987, I testified for Susan Collins to be confirmed as Maine Commissioner of Professional and Financial Regulation, a position both my wife and I had previously held.  My support proved justified as she did well in the post.  She deserves great credit for her efforts reforming Workers Compensation.

Collins was smart, competent and a member of a prominent Republican family that placed public service above political partisanship.  She once told me that she prized that tradition and sought to honor it.  But political moderation became impossible.  Adjusting to the GOP’s rightward shift became both a challenge and the ultimate source of the loss of her Senate seat.

When she went to Washington in 1997, she embodied that moderate tradition and promised to serve no more than two terms, evidence of her Senate tenure being public service not the beginning of a career stretching until 2027.  The changing political atmosphere and her own political ambition had their effect on her moderate stance.

In Maine, the Republican Party abandoned its good-government legacy for more conservative partisanship.  To avert challenges from the right, Collins accommodated the new GOP.  She maintained the image of civil moderation, allowing the GOP to hold onto the Senate seat by tolerating her lack of complete loyalty.

In Washington, she also adjusted to conservative reality.  To gain Senate influence, she had to serve her party’s needs, accepting its national policies while her demeanor allowed her to continue to project moderation at home.  But she needed to manage her political balance as Maine moved toward the Democrats.  By 2020, her election margin had narrowed.

She served with fellow Republican Senator Olympia Snowe, a moderate dedicated to compromise.  The contrast showed in the office space and committee assignments each was given by GOP leadership.  Collins could see the rewards of party loyalty, while Snowe stuck to her independence.  Ultimately Snowe chose to leave the Senate, while Collins climbed.

In Congress, members vote themselves “earmarks,” payments enabling each to take credit for bringing home federal money.  Earmarks were temporarily abandoned, but returned when incumbents could not resist their value in convincing voters to send them back for more.  To help her keep her seat, the party made Collins a prime harvester of federal cash.

With a bit of good luck, Collins rose to leadership of the Appropriations Committee, supposedly having a key role in deciding federal spending.  That helped in doling out earmarks, but the GOP’s unquestioning acceptance of Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill meant her legislative power was limited.  She never exercised the influence she might have expected, but she hung on.

She could not use her almost demure image as protection in every situation.  She continues to be attacked for her vote to confirm Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court.  To many, he seemed sure to vote to overturn Roe v. Wade, but Collins interpreted her interview with him as assurance that he would not reverse its precedent.

The undercurrent of his failure to perform as she expected was that either she had been easily duped or that she was not telling voters the truth when she went along with Trump’s nominee.  She could never overcome such negative vibes.

Though the Maine media may have cast her as a titan based on her six terms, she isn’t in the same league as Margaret Chase Smith, Ed Muskie, Bill Cohen or George Mitchell.  All of them became nationally known figures and took political risks, bringing reflected credit to Maine.  That aura may still matter to Maine voters, and it was missing.

Her claim to moderation became hollow as time passed.  She occasionally expressed opposition to Trump, though it usually made no difference in critical votes.  She was not a leader who boldly took him on, ready to take political risks.  Her statements lacked force and became temporizing – speaking just enough to suit the needs of the moment.

Any person who holds public office long enough loses support, because some constituents will always be disappointed by their actions.  To some degree, political campaigning is meant to remind voters of the best and gloss over problems.  Campaigns depend on attacking the opponent.  Collins did all that, and ads run by her backers conflicted with her image.

She lost because of Trump, though not only because she had followed the loyalist GOP leadership.  She failed to recognize that her earmarks for firehouses meant little compared with the cost of gas, heating oil and food, increased by his tariffs and, above all, the Iran war.

On February 28, the day the war began, Trump began to lose the midterms, ultimately toppling the Republican Congress.  Collins might have saved herself if she had taken the risk of becoming the outspoken leader Maine wanted and needed.  The winner by default was Troy Jackson. 

Friday, November 6, 2026

The real and permanent effect of the midterms

 

The real and permanent effect of the midterms

More than who governs was decided

 

Gordon L. Weil

Benjamin Franklin famously told a questioner that the draft Constitution created “a republic if you can keep it.”

The midterm elections have similarly created an historic opportunity, if we can use it.  The liberal democracy that lasted from 1933 until 2017 must be replaced.  Trumpist authoritarianism has been rejected as its successor.  The U.S. now has the chance for a do-over.

What will be done with the opportunity depends on whether the Democrats try to meet public needs and undo Trump’s damage or resort mostly to feel-good retaliation.  It also depends on whether the surviving Republicans are ready to join in governing or can’t get over their loyalty to a failed president.  The next two years will tell people if even more reform is needed.

Whatever happens, the basis of the future may have been built this year.

A major concern of the extreme MAGA right was the demographic message that sometime in the next 20 years, the American majority will be non-white.  Race-based redistricting and closing down non-white immigration, legal or illegal, is evidence of this thinking.

Throughout most of U.S. history, running the country was the birthright of white men. Everybody else either stayed in the kitchen or were treated like immature children (to put slavery, racism and discrimination in its best light).  This election marked the end of that history.

The election results show both the inevitability of demographic change and that many white people don’t worry about it.  The hallmarks of change, real and permanent, are all around. 

The House of Representatives is to be led by a Black.  The Senate by a Jew.  Texas by a Latina.  New Mexico by a member of the Laguna Pueblo tribe.

Among the most stunning signs of change is the likely election of the first Black senator from Mississippi not to have been chosen under federal occupation during Reconstruction.  Though not political, another indicator is the pride of a once anti-Catholic country in the leadership of an American pope.  

More than 100 Democratic women are expected to serve in the House along with almost 30 Republican women.  While these numbers do not reflect the percentage of women in the population, they will have a strong influence on public policy.  Speaker Nancy Pelosi was a trailblazer.  The trail is now open.  The majority leader will be a woman.  

On the Senate side, there have been 27 women from both parties serving.  Next year, for the first time, three Black women will be senators, and a state will be represented by two women of color.

In state capitols, at least 17 governors will be women, mostly Democrats.   Nationwide, about one-third of state legislators are women.  Both numbers are increasing.

The number of Blacks in high public office is also growing.  Florida and Georgia, once Confederate states, elected Black governors, one a Republican and the other a Democrat.  There will be five Black governors, four newly elected.  There may be as many as seven African American senators. 

This is progress for seating Blacks, but it is only a partial success.   The Supreme Court has placed obstacles in the path of electing Blacks to Congress by allowing race-based redistricting in some states.  The long-ago Massachusetts creator of gerrymandering probably did not envisage the tool being used for racial discrimination.

The trends toward a more open government have been under way for decades.  But the Democratic victories this year have pushed them ahead farther and faster.  If the Democrats need to find a common policy shared by moderates and progressives, it could be continuing their efforts to open more doors for more people.

The Republicans talk about their need to attract minorities.  The elections this year show they have failed.  The Democrats have “the big mo” –momentum.  The GOP has to stop itself from going backwards.

Trump, who is the godfather of Cabinet firings, has dismissed only women so far.  This would be a good moment for him to clean house, though he would surely lose some champion sycophants.  The most likely candidate seems to be Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, whose abuse of power otherwise sets him up for impeachment.

Most of this year’s new faces have risen to public office from modest beginnings.  They represent a triumph of merit over power derived from tax breaks, political skill over brute financial force.  The American system makes both possible, but voters have shown their sentiments by rating corruption as one key reason for their dumping Republicans.

Trump could be a good Republican and halt deficit spending.  That might mean raising the tax bills on himself and his Fortune 400 friends.  The rule of celebrity and wealth, with its gilded office, overblown East Wing, and triumphal arch, must end.  Trump should take a good look at himself in the reflecting pool.

Otherwise, 2026 was just the beginning.


Sunday, November 1, 2026

Voters on brink of a major correction --more at stake than next Congress

Voters on brink of a major correction

More at stake than next Congress

 

Gordon L. Weil

On election night, the congressional seat count will be the focus.

Will Trump and his MAGA Republicans be rejected?  Will Democratic progressives advance their movement at the expense of moderates?  Whose votes made the difference – women, young, stay-at-homes?   Pundits, candidates and campaigns will have ready answers.  But there may be more to the outcome than these immediate conclusions. 

Three currents run through the electorate.   Right-wing Trumpers, traditional moderates and left-wing progressives have been seeking acceptance by the voters.  Just as 2020 signaled a turning point with Trump’s comeback and his emphasis on authoritarian government, voters this year may make a correction, either returning to moderation or turning toward liberalism.

The U.S. is an historically conservative country.  But the Great Depression so disrupted it that an enhanced role for government under the liberal New Deal became necessary and possible.  Social Security was its hallmark. 

After the Second World War, the U.S. tried to live up to the lessons it had learned.  Reacting to the defeat of Nazi fascism and the growing rivalry with Communist dictatorship, the country stayed the course.

One symbol of the new American center was the Supreme Court decision ending legal racial discrimination.  A national road network was built for the first time.  Voting rights were extended to more of the population, notably Blacks and the young.  Medicare was created.  Environmental rules began to be written.

Congress could often find compromises on major issues.   While some deep disagreements existed, congressional cooperation reflected a broad national consensus based on shared values.  Each side accepted some of the arguments of the other, and losses did not result in all-out political war.

But voters became discontented, because the government, though liberated from historic conservatism, had not paid adequate attention to the hopes and needs of many people.  Discrimination persisted.  Prosperity did not live up to political promises.  Taxes had grown too far and too fast.   Some voters believed they were losing control.

People increasingly wanted change and were frustrated when it did not happen.   Donald Trump, searching for a winning platform, cultivated this discontent and made it into his program.  Though to many it seemed like a marginal view, he managed to use his celebrity to develop and exploit and grow this part of the electorate.

Surprisingly to many, he succeeded.  He was unconstrained by historical norms and drew support from many who gave change a higher priority than continuity.  In 2024, he defeated the moderate center that had failed to bring about change.  Trump took his victory as not only for a mandate for his right-wing movement but as an endorsement of his free-wheeling, egotistical style.

Given broad authority by the Supreme Court, he exceeded even the greatly loosened norms.   He openly enriched himself.  He began a war he could not finish, imposing heavy costs on average people, including even his most steadfast supporters.  He tried to manipulate the legal system.  He bragged and he threatened, even his closest allies.  His ambitions grew, but his popularity fell.

Because he was so closely identified with the Republican Party that had been swallowed by his MAGA, his problems became his party’s problems.   This year’s elections are a judgment on Trump, which he invited, but also on the future of the movement he has headed.

Just as the right became unhappy with politics as usual, so did the left.  The government’s agenda looks backwards and favors the wealthy elite over average people.  The left wants to restore and augment government to support the broad popular needs, such as for health care.  The right scorns it as socialist, but it has sought to make community interest equal to individual interest.

Progressives seek government social benefit programs, financed by higher taxes on the wealthy who have been favored by Trump.  They might support his closed borders but not indiscriminate deportations.  They respond to calls for change by forward-looking policies rather than a return to an unrecoverable past.

The Democratic progressives have been tested by these elections.  Voters may reveal wider acceptance of the progressive agenda or simply conclude that it is an isolated outburst of frustration whose goals are not broadly popular.

The returns will show if Trump’s MAGA can withstand its setbacks and continue to rule with a brand of authoritarianism that suits the public mood for dismantling much of what the moderates built.  If it has failed, it may leave behind thousands of bitter and disaffected citizens.

The progressives have faced closer scrutiny by the voters.  If they succeed, they will be serious contenders to lead the Democratic Party in 2028.  If they have failed, they probably will hang on to fight another day.

The future of the moderates depends on whether the traditional GOP can be revived and the Democrats’ platform, dictated by whoever emerges to lead them.   That process begins now.

 

Friday, October 30, 2026

The GOP: bitter, but possibly liberated as elections bring a chance for change

 

The GOP: bitter, but possibly liberated

Elections bring a chance for change

 

Gordon L. Weil

In the wake of next week’s midterm elections, two images of the Republican Party may emerge, one a renewal of bitter conflict and the other more constructive.

One will be the MAGA reaction to the results.   Trump has created the model of what you do when you lose an election.   The losers charge it was tainted by illegal voting and dishonest vote counting.   That leads to claims that the election was invalid and the results should be nullified.  The challenges are settled in court.   Meanwhile, the winners cannot take office.

It’s not clear what would happen next, because, lacking evidence, it never gets that far.  Possibly, new elections.  Certainly, confidence in the democratic system would be undermined with the aim of more authoritarian rule.  Chaos is the goal, not a different outcome.  That’s what occurred in 2020.

The Democrats seem to have helped the Trump effort to question the results.  In Alaska, they found a person with an almost identical name as incumbent GOP Sen. Dan S. Sullivan to run with the intent of confusing voters.   That’s not illegal, but the revelation is not likely to help the Democratic candidate.

Even before the election, Trump’s Department of Justice asked the federal district court to block the result if the senator loses but would have won with the votes of the duplicate candidate.

Such an order would not be possible.  The court would have to assume, without knowing, who voted for the copy candidate and why.  

The DOJ probably knows that.  But the case boosts Trump’s claim that the Democrats undermine free elections.  Before the revelation of their promoting the copy, they had denied any connection with his candidacy.  It matters little that the Alaska situation does not involve either phantom voters or dishonest vote counting; it adds to the atmosphere of distrust.

A Blue Wave, with big Democratic margins, could discourage GOP claims, but challenges are highly likely.  The Democrats have set up an election protection task force.  Federal district courts should be ready to decide promptly unless the Republicans have evidence and not mere suspicion. 

The immediate aftermath of the elections could produce the political chaos that voting irregularity charges are meant to cause.   The lame duck Congress will try to pass many Trump policies while the GOP still controls the government and uncertainty swirls.   The election effect won’t be over until the new Congress is seated.  

If the Democrats gain control of one or both houses of Congress in January, they may investigate the Trump administration and will surely hold hearings to restage those conducted by the GOP.   They will try to block Trump’s judicial and executive nominations and will try to take control of the legislative agenda.  Republicans will resist.

Democrats and many political analysts assume that the GOP members will remain almost monolithic in their support for the president and his agenda, just as they were in the first two years of this Trump term.  Whatever the Democrats may try, they assume a united GOP opposition, still committed to the Trump agenda.

This assumption could be incorrect.  The election may not only reshape the Democrats, but the results may influence congressional Republicans.  Some Republicans may be liberated from their blind loyalty to Trump.

Even if Trump himself remains unyielding, Republican members of Congress will most likely have to deal with the realities highlighted by the elections.  Congressional Republicans may increasingly want to determine their own political fates, rather than falling in line behind a weakened and lame duck Trump.  

They would have good reasons to change course.

1. Trump is deeply unpopular.   Voters have begun to focus on what they see as his corruption and his willingness to attack anyone or any country disagreeing with him.  He is not only a lame duck, but his endorsement of primary opponents in 2028 may carry little weight, meaning GOP legislators have less to fear.

2. Bringing down prices and inflation tops the agenda.  As Bill Clinton said, “It’s not about woke.  It’s about broke.”  Trump’s social policy focus has fail to take attention away from the economic hardship of many Americans.

3. Trump’s immigration policy worked, but his deportation policy didn’t.  ICE should stop tracking down respectable, long-term residents, who contribute to the economy and focus on lawbreakers, as promised.   

4. The unpopular Iran war must be ended, and Ukraine should be supported.

5. Issues like Social Security cannot be ignored any longer and virtually require either an overwhelming majority of one party or really working across the aisle, thus strengthening Congress.

The Republicans will have a choice between fighting a rearguard battle supporting Trump trying to maintain some control by blocking the Democrats or reading the election results as a call to begin the renewal of the Grand Old Party.


Sunday, October 25, 2026

Congress again cedes power to president

 

Congress again cedes power to president

The case for sunset law

 

Gordon L. Weil

Congress is routinely criticized for its inaction, weakness, and failure to perform its constitutional duties.  Two recent cases prove the point.

Upon his return from one of his regular visits to Ukraine, Lindsay Graham, a Republican senator from South Carolina, suddenly died.  President Zelenskyy lost one his most staunch American supporters, a leader in opposition to Russia’s war against his country.  Graham was also an ally of President Trump.

With strong GOP majority support, both houses of Congress promptly passed a bill to impose tight controls on the oil sales that Russia was using to finance its war.  The bill was named in Graham’s honor and was signed by Trump, meaning the law would go into effect almost immediately.

Concerned about the effect of rising oil prices on Republican chances in the midterm elections and continuing to be enthralled by Putin’s autocratic control of Russia, Trump used a waiver in the Lindsay O. Graham Act to suspend limits it imposed.  This action accompanied his decision to allow American diesel purchases directly from Russia.

In effect, the law was just for show and Congress had done nothing, missing the opportunity to take real action on the Ukraine war, using the situation created by Graham’s unexpected death.  In effect, it committed legislative suicide.

Under the act, the president may waive any sanction on Russia by simply filing a report with Congress explaining the justification for the waiver. No further action is required, and the waiver has no time limit.

Presidential termination of any sanction requires congressional review and risks rejection, subject to the need to overcome a presidential veto.  Termination could be irrelevant if a president’s waiver continued endlessly.  Congress again recovered none of the powers it has ceded to the president over decades, retreating from its leadership role under the Constitution.

The result, as shown by Trump’s action, is that the bill is meaningless.  And so is Congress.  It is reasonable to wonder if any member ever read the bill through to the end or if they concurred in an act that they knew was an empty gesture.  If they had thought it could be politically useful to have voted for it, Trump deprived them of that small benefit.

In the second case, Trump took advantage of congressional inaction.

In 1930, Congress passed the highly protectionist Smoot-Hawley tariff.  History has assigned it a role as one of the major contributors to the Great Depression that devastated the economy of the 1930s.  

The act was so extreme that some of the authority given to the president had not been used during any of the next 16 presidencies.  An obvious failure, it went unused, but Congress failed to repeal it.

Believing that the American trade deficit is evidence of extensive exploitation by other countries, Trump launched high tariffs against most other countries.  He targeted Canada, which, unlike other countries, responded by raising its own tariffs.  Two-way retaliation emerged, but Trump believed that Canada favored other countries, which had not lifted their tariffs.

Section 338 of Smoot-Hawley gives the president power to retaliate against other countries if they discriminate against American exports, and he used it to impose 50 percent duties on Canada.  This law escapes most of the limits that allowed the Supreme Court to strike down his broader effort to raise tariffs.  Its use has created real hostility between Canada and the U.S.

These two cases reveal defects in the relationship between the president and Congress.  Limiting itself to general policy and glossing over key administrative details, Congress gives the president wide powers in carrying out its intent.  The president’s power is so unrestrained, that the chief executive may counteract the very intent of the legislation.

The Supreme Court has found that the president has almost unlimited power.  The only checks on his discretion are impeachment and conviction or elections.  Once granted a power, the president can distort or ignore its limits.  Only the Court can determine if the president violated the law, but it sees almost all presidential actions as protected by executive authority.

These cases offer two messages about congressional authority over presidents.

First, all legislation giving any authority to the president should be subject to sunset. After a limited period of time, the grant of executive powers would automatically terminate unless renewed for a similar period by subsequent votes.  It would be worth exploring if Congress could now enact a sunset rule applying to all current laws.

Second, a bipartisan body should be formed to identify laws that are duplicative, unused or in need of updating. Congress could then be required to take action on them.

If Congress continues giving presidents unlimited authority on the assumption that an elected leader will follow democratic norms, it will continue to see its power eroded.  It has options; it should use them.