Trump defeat slows right-wing surge
Youth becomes a political force
Gordon L. Weil
By the start of the year, panic colored political
commentary. The Trump presidency was
becoming the model for other nations moving to create right-wing governments. He had legitimized and made respectable a
shift toward conservative populism.
Wins by AfD, a right-wing party urging Germany to get over
its Nazi guilt, and the unpopularity of the country’s leader were signs that the
right was climbing. If MAGA worked so
well in the U.S., its appeal could be exported; Vice President JD Vance held an
unprecedented meeting with the AfD leaders.
After the German state elections, forecasts of coming right-wing
election wins have extended to France, Brazil and other countries almost as a
foregone conclusion. On the eve of
Hungary’s presidential election, Vance travelled to Budapest to extend MAGA’s
embrace to the country’s right-wing leader.
The expected right-wing wave faltered. Trump’s America had been the leader in this
political change, setting a pattern for many other countries, but it has
suddenly become the follower as other countries rejected the American model. This rejection has been sweeping the world,
making it doubtful if the right will prevail in France or Germany.
In Hungary, Prime Minister Viktor Orbán had been the
hope of the right. He had turned his country into the major irritant within
NATO and the EU, and he drew closer to Russia, despite its aggression against
Ukraine. He was brought to the U.S. as a
cheerleader for American conservatives.
After the elections, Orbán and his party were out, replaced
by Peter Magyar. The new prime minister
immediately reversed right-wing policies and restored his nation’s ties to
regional organizations.
In Serbia, President Aleksander Vučič, head of the
right-wing governing party, decided to try a move to become prime minister through
an early election. He lost to the
Student List, the opposition that developed in just a few months, even without a
leader. Serbia’s change paralleled what
had happened earlier in Hungary.
In Brazil, the right tried to restore the rule of Javier Bolsonaro,
a president imprisoned for election tampering.
His son, Jair, openly favored by Trump, was defeated as was his father by
the venerable liberal Lula da Silva.
Facing his own criminal charges, the younger Bolsonaro fled to the U.S.
and was admitted by the Trump administration.
In India, the Cockroach movement, led by discontented
students, has taken on the regime of the increasingly authoritarian Prime
Minister Narendra Modi. Street
demonstrations have weakened Modi’s hold on power.
In France, where a presidential election will be held next
year, Marine LePen has been seen as the hope of the right. But once again, it was opposition started by
students that has made the election outcome less predictable.
In Britain, the center-left Labour Party government gave way
to new party leadership that has seemed poised to move more to the left.
As quickly as conservative populism had arisen, it began to
lose favor. Opposition, especially by
young people, challenged it. Conservatism
had owed much of its popularity to Trump’s success. Then, the Republican right-wing
suffered a stunning defeat in the midterm elections. The U.S. rejected right-wing conservatism just
as others had. It is no longer the
beacon for change.
In the U.S., only the vestiges of MAGA and a weakened
president remain with any power. Trump’s moves from tariffs to his profiting
from the presidency to the costs of the Iran war brought out a coalition that
reversed the trend toward authoritarianism.
It had seemed that everything had to get worse before it got
better. Finally, that happened.
A common theme has been evident as the right-wing losses
have mounted: the Iran war was a devastating mistake. The extreme right had opposed war, and Trump
promised to avoid it. Then, he chose to
launch the Iran war. There was no quick
victory and, even worse, it drove up prices everywhere in the world without any
prospect of when they might again be affordable.
Trump’s massive error not only took down the Republican
Congress but contributed to the defeat of his allies elsewhere. They had cozied up to Trump, believing he
represented the future, but they paid the ultimate political price for their
loyalty. His mistake became their
mistake.
In one major way, as his friends went to defeat, they
offered him something positive. The U.S. had geared up for legal wars over
supposed voter fraud. But from Hungary
to Brazil, leaders accepted, often gracefully, their defeat.
Trump accepted the GOP defeat without that expected war, but
not without grumbling. In Israel, Prime
Minister Netanyahu missed the message and reflexively charged voting irregularities
in Arab areas, but his claims were promptly rejected by the official election
commission.
Right-wing populism may not have been delivered a fatal blow
this year, but political events culminating in the midterms, slowed its surge
on the world scene.
To readers:
Last week I noted that Susan Collins had served six terms. That was incorrect; she will have served five
terms.
Another note on Collins. Watch how she votes between now and the end of her term in January. She can now afford to show her moderate side and resist Trump at times or she can reveal that the voters correctly concluded she had shed her moderation.