Showing posts with label 2026 elections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2026 elections. Show all posts

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Why Sen. Susan Collins lost: the demise of a moderate


Why Susan Collins lost

The demise of a moderate

 

Gordon L. Weil

In 1987, I testified for Susan Collins to be confirmed as Maine Commissioner of Professional and Financial Regulation, a position both my wife and I had previously held.  My support proved justified as she did well in the post.  She deserves great credit for her efforts reforming Workers Compensation.

Collins was smart, competent and a member of a prominent Republican family that placed public service above political partisanship.  She once told me that she prized that tradition and sought to honor it.  But political moderation became impossible.  Adjusting to the GOP’s rightward shift became both a challenge and the ultimate source of the loss of her Senate seat.

When she went to Washington in 1997, she embodied that moderate tradition and promised to serve no more than two terms, evidence of her Senate tenure being public service not the beginning of a career stretching until 2027.  The changing political atmosphere and her own political ambition had their effect on her moderate stance.

In Maine, the Republican Party abandoned its good-government legacy for more conservative partisanship.  To avert challenges from the right, Collins accommodated the new GOP.  She maintained the image of civil moderation, allowing the GOP to hold onto the Senate seat by tolerating her lack of complete loyalty.

In Washington, she also adjusted to conservative reality.  To gain Senate influence, she had to serve her party’s needs, accepting its national policies while her demeanor allowed her to continue to project moderation at home.  But she needed to manage her political balance as Maine moved toward the Democrats.  By 2020, her election margin had narrowed.

She served with fellow Republican Senator Olympia Snowe, a moderate dedicated to compromise.  The contrast showed in the office space and committee assignments each was given by GOP leadership.  Collins could see the rewards of party loyalty, while Snowe stuck to her independence.  Ultimately Snowe chose to leave the Senate, while Collins climbed.

In Congress, members vote themselves “earmarks,” payments enabling each to take credit for bringing home federal money.  Earmarks were temporarily abandoned, but returned when incumbents could not resist their value in convincing voters to send them back for more.  To help her keep her seat, the party made Collins a prime harvester of federal cash.

With a bit of good luck, Collins rose to leadership of the Appropriations Committee, supposedly having a key role in deciding federal spending.  That helped in doling out earmarks, but the GOP’s unquestioning acceptance of Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill meant her legislative power was limited.  She never exercised the influence she might have expected, but she hung on.

She could not use her almost demure image as protection in every situation.  She continues to be attacked for her vote to confirm Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court.  To many, he seemed sure to vote to overturn Roe v. Wade, but Collins interpreted her interview with him as assurance that he would not reverse its precedent.

The undercurrent of his failure to perform as she expected was that either she had been easily duped or that she was not telling voters the truth when she went along with Trump’s nominee.  She could never overcome such negative vibes.

Though the Maine media may have cast her as a titan based on her six terms, she isn’t in the same league as Margaret Chase Smith, Ed Muskie, Bill Cohen or George Mitchell.  All of them became nationally known figures and took political risks, bringing reflected credit to Maine.  That aura may still matter to Maine voters, and it was missing.

Her claim to moderation became hollow as time passed.  She occasionally expressed opposition to Trump, though it usually made no difference in critical votes.  She was not a leader who boldly took him on, ready to take political risks.  Her statements lacked force and became temporizing – speaking just enough to suit the needs of the moment.

Any person who holds public office long enough loses support, because some constituents will always be disappointed by their actions.  To some degree, political campaigning is meant to remind voters of the best and gloss over problems.  Campaigns depend on attacking the opponent.  Collins did all that, and ads run by her backers conflicted with her image.

She lost because of Trump, though not only because she had followed the loyalist GOP leadership.  She failed to recognize that her earmarks for firehouses meant little compared with the cost of gas, heating oil and food, increased by his tariffs and, above all, the Iran war.

On February 28, the day the war began, Trump began to lose the midterms, ultimately toppling the Republican Congress.  Collins might have saved herself if she had taken the risk of becoming the outspoken leader Maine wanted and needed.  The winner by default was Troy Jackson. 

Friday, November 6, 2026

The real and permanent effect of the midterms

 

The real and permanent effect of the midterms

More than who governs was decided

 

Gordon L. Weil

Benjamin Franklin famously told a questioner that the draft Constitution created “a republic if you can keep it.”

The midterm elections have similarly created an historic opportunity, if we can use it.  The liberal democracy that lasted from 1933 until 2017 must be replaced.  Trumpist authoritarianism has been rejected as its successor.  The U.S. now has the chance for a do-over.

What will be done with the opportunity depends on whether the Democrats try to meet public needs and undo Trump’s damage or resort mostly to feel-good retaliation.  It also depends on whether the surviving Republicans are ready to join in governing or can’t get over their loyalty to a failed president.  The next two years will tell people if even more reform is needed.

Whatever happens, the basis of the future may have been built this year.

A major concern of the extreme MAGA right was the demographic message that sometime in the next 20 years, the American majority will be non-white.  Race-based redistricting and closing down non-white immigration, legal or illegal, is evidence of this thinking.

Throughout most of U.S. history, running the country was the birthright of white men. Everybody else either stayed in the kitchen or were treated like immature children (to put slavery, racism and discrimination in its best light).  This election marked the end of that history.

The election results show both the inevitability of demographic change and that many white people don’t worry about it.  The hallmarks of change, real and permanent, are all around. 

The House of Representatives is to be led by a Black.  The Senate by a Jew.  Texas by a Latina.  New Mexico by a member of the Laguna Pueblo tribe.

Among the most stunning signs of change is the likely election of the first Black senator from Mississippi not to have been chosen under federal occupation during Reconstruction.  Though not political, another indicator is the pride of a once anti-Catholic country in the leadership of an American pope.  

More than 100 Democratic women are expected to serve in the House along with almost 30 Republican women.  While these numbers do not reflect the percentage of women in the population, they will have a strong influence on public policy.  Speaker Nancy Pelosi was a trailblazer.  The trail is now open.  The majority leader will be a woman.  

On the Senate side, there have been 27 women from both parties serving.  Next year, for the first time, three Black women will be senators, and a state will be represented by two women of color.

In state capitols, at least 17 governors will be women, mostly Democrats.   Nationwide, about one-third of state legislators are women.  Both numbers are increasing.

The number of Blacks in high public office is also growing.  Florida and Georgia, once Confederate states, elected Black governors, one a Republican and the other a Democrat.  There will be five Black governors, four newly elected.  There may be as many as seven African American senators. 

This is progress for seating Blacks, but it is only a partial success.   The Supreme Court has placed obstacles in the path of electing Blacks to Congress by allowing race-based redistricting in some states.  The long-ago Massachusetts creator of gerrymandering probably did not envisage the tool being used for racial discrimination.

The trends toward a more open government have been under way for decades.  But the Democratic victories this year have pushed them ahead farther and faster.  If the Democrats need to find a common policy shared by moderates and progressives, it could be continuing their efforts to open more doors for more people.

The Republicans talk about their need to attract minorities.  The elections this year show they have failed.  The Democrats have “the big mo” –momentum.  The GOP has to stop itself from going backwards.

Trump, who is the godfather of Cabinet firings, has dismissed only women so far.  This would be a good moment for him to clean house, though he would surely lose some champion sycophants.  The most likely candidate seems to be Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, whose abuse of power otherwise sets him up for impeachment.

Most of this year’s new faces have risen to public office from modest beginnings.  They represent a triumph of merit over power derived from tax breaks, political skill over brute financial force.  The American system makes both possible, but voters have shown their sentiments by rating corruption as one key reason for their dumping Republicans.

Trump could be a good Republican and halt deficit spending.  That might mean raising the tax bills on himself and his Fortune 400 friends.  The rule of celebrity and wealth, with its gilded office, overblown East Wing, and triumphal arch, must end.  Trump should take a good look at himself in the reflecting pool.

Otherwise, 2026 was just the beginning.


Sunday, November 1, 2026

Voters on brink of a major correction --more at stake than next Congress

Voters on brink of a major correction

More at stake than next Congress

 

Gordon L. Weil

On election night, the congressional seat count will be the focus.

Will Trump and his MAGA Republicans be rejected?  Will Democratic progressives advance their movement at the expense of moderates?  Whose votes made the difference – women, young, stay-at-homes?   Pundits, candidates and campaigns will have ready answers.  But there may be more to the outcome than these immediate conclusions. 

Three currents run through the electorate.   Right-wing Trumpers, traditional moderates and left-wing progressives have been seeking acceptance by the voters.  Just as 2020 signaled a turning point with Trump’s comeback and his emphasis on authoritarian government, voters this year may make a correction, either returning to moderation or turning toward liberalism.

The U.S. is an historically conservative country.  But the Great Depression so disrupted it that an enhanced role for government under the liberal New Deal became necessary and possible.  Social Security was its hallmark. 

After the Second World War, the U.S. tried to live up to the lessons it had learned.  Reacting to the defeat of Nazi fascism and the growing rivalry with Communist dictatorship, the country stayed the course.

One symbol of the new American center was the Supreme Court decision ending legal racial discrimination.  A national road network was built for the first time.  Voting rights were extended to more of the population, notably Blacks and the young.  Medicare was created.  Environmental rules began to be written.

Congress could often find compromises on major issues.   While some deep disagreements existed, congressional cooperation reflected a broad national consensus based on shared values.  Each side accepted some of the arguments of the other, and losses did not result in all-out political war.

But voters became discontented, because the government, though liberated from historic conservatism, had not paid adequate attention to the hopes and needs of many people.  Discrimination persisted.  Prosperity did not live up to political promises.  Taxes had grown too far and too fast.   Some voters believed they were losing control.

People increasingly wanted change and were frustrated when it did not happen.   Donald Trump, searching for a winning platform, cultivated this discontent and made it into his program.  Though to many it seemed like a marginal view, he managed to use his celebrity to develop and exploit and grow this part of the electorate.

Surprisingly to many, he succeeded.  He was unconstrained by historical norms and drew support from many who gave change a higher priority than continuity.  In 2024, he defeated the moderate center that had failed to bring about change.  Trump took his victory as not only for a mandate for his right-wing movement but as an endorsement of his free-wheeling, egotistical style.

Given broad authority by the Supreme Court, he exceeded even the greatly loosened norms.   He openly enriched himself.  He began a war he could not finish, imposing heavy costs on average people, including even his most steadfast supporters.  He tried to manipulate the legal system.  He bragged and he threatened, even his closest allies.  His ambitions grew, but his popularity fell.

Because he was so closely identified with the Republican Party that had been swallowed by his MAGA, his problems became his party’s problems.   This year’s elections are a judgment on Trump, which he invited, but also on the future of the movement he has headed.

Just as the right became unhappy with politics as usual, so did the left.  The government’s agenda looks backwards and favors the wealthy elite over average people.  The left wants to restore and augment government to support the broad popular needs, such as for health care.  The right scorns it as socialist, but it has sought to make community interest equal to individual interest.

Progressives seek government social benefit programs, financed by higher taxes on the wealthy who have been favored by Trump.  They might support his closed borders but not indiscriminate deportations.  They respond to calls for change by forward-looking policies rather than a return to an unrecoverable past.

The Democratic progressives have been tested by these elections.  Voters may reveal wider acceptance of the progressive agenda or simply conclude that it is an isolated outburst of frustration whose goals are not broadly popular.

The returns will show if Trump’s MAGA can withstand its setbacks and continue to rule with a brand of authoritarianism that suits the public mood for dismantling much of what the moderates built.  If it has failed, it may leave behind thousands of bitter and disaffected citizens.

The progressives have faced closer scrutiny by the voters.  If they succeed, they will be serious contenders to lead the Democratic Party in 2028.  If they have failed, they probably will hang on to fight another day.

The future of the moderates depends on whether the traditional GOP can be revived and the Democrats’ platform, dictated by whoever emerges to lead them.   That process begins now.

 

Friday, October 9, 2026

Voters: double down on Trump or fold? National referendum on now


Voters: double down on Trump or fold?

National referendum on now

 

Gordon L. Weil

The pollsters are running wild.

As the U.S. approaches Election Day, forecasting about the possible outcomes dominates the political news.  The basis for the forecasts is often poll results. And many of those results fall within the so-called “margin of error.”

In reality, most polling should be read to say that the outcome is uncertain, so voters better cast their ballots on the possibility that they might determine the winner.  Polls can become an election factor by encouraging voter behavior, but they are given far more weight than they are worth.

This column has often criticized polling.   Its reliability is weakened by one or more factors:  the ways in which the survey sample is collected, how the answers are massaged, the survey questionnaire and its potential bias, its lack of timeliness and the tendency of pollsters to rely on one another to verify their findings.

Often, pollsters focus on “likely voters.”   What tells them if a voter is likely to cast a ballot?  The voter.  And that includes one other factor raising doubt: is the interviewee being honest?  And how representative of a larger constituency are the many people who simply decline to be surveyed?

The bottom line must be that the people who vote will differ from the hypothetically representative people in a survey.  How much?  That gets back to the question of turnout, varying from place to place, issue to issue or candidate to candidate.

The congressional elections this year look to constitute a referendum on President Trump, which he would like it to be.  What is his outlook?

To begin, he can rely on his core, the faithful MAGA adherents.  Supporting him is the essence of their political participation.  Just as he claims, he is never wrong about anything.  For them, when Trump takes a position, that position is, by definition, correct.  If he abruptly changes his position, that’s because he knows more than anybody else about underlying reality.

The Trump core is likely to vote.

Closely related to the core are voters he has convinced that the Democratic Party is out to destroy America, because it is socialist or even communist.  To convince people of this view, he must rewrite history, which works for those whose knowledge of history is shaped by social media and is mostly wrong.  They vote for Trumpers, who will block the supposedly devious Democrats.

The Democratic doubters are likely to vote for GOP candidates, though some may choose to abstain.

Finally, he would rely on voters whose allegiance to the Republican Party is ingrained, possibly by family or neighborhood custom.   His takeover of the GOP pays off when traditional adherents remain committed, blind to his departure from Republican orthodoxy like the need to cut deficits.  This may be especially true in dwindling rural areas.

Traditional Republicans could choose to stay home.  While some will remain loyal, others are angry about their cost of living and government spending.  A minority might believe the Democrats could do better.  Some, now fully aware of the extent to which Trump has turned the presidency to personal profit, will want to openly reject him.

National policy is often something of an abstraction for voters, which explains why foreign policy issues are secondary.   The practical implications of key policies – income, prices, opportunity, nondiscrimination – matter more than policies removed from daily life.  Sometimes, of course, people vote on social issues to the point of ignoring their own wellbeing.

A theme of recent elections has been the message that people want change.  Government is not yielding results that improve their lives.  The elections of Barack Obama and Donald Trump were essential expressions of that message.  But reality has to reflect the results that would have to fulfill promises for change.

Trump’s charisma and exploitation of presidential power suggested that he could bring real change.  His policies on immigration, environment, energy, and civil liberties carried his unique stamp.

His greatest problem may have been failure to keep America out of war, as he had promised, and the abandonment of his winning promise to bring prices under control and open economic opportunity.  A failed understanding of economics and an overly exalted belief in American power led to the clear failure of his trade policy and his Iran war.

Promises were not kept at a cost to the people, and they noticed.

Trump’s belief in himself extends to a belief that, if the election comes down to him, the voters will keep faith in him no matter their own worries.  MAGA has momentum, he believes.  To help it, he proposes massive taxpayer supported handouts.

Will voters double down on their commitment to Trump or turn away from him in their own self-interest?  A divided people, not the polls and pundits, will ultimately provide the answer.

 

  

Sunday, October 4, 2026

Voters can restore checks and balances


Voters can restore checks and balances

People could take power back, overrule Congress, Supreme Court

 

Gordon L. Weil

Political talk focuses increasingly on whether democracy can survive the Supreme Courts’ grant of almost regal powers to the president and Donald Trump’s exploitation of virtually absolute authority that he gained from it.  

If the Court envisaged any limit on the president, it would have to come from an independent Congress.  But that has been sorely lacking.

American democracy is supposed to mean that the voters choose the people who will lead the legislative and executive branches of government, and they can change their leaders through regular elections.  Leaders can embody and represent the majority will and serve for the benefit of all.

In practice, at the federal level, it doesn’t work that way, producing popular discontent with the government.

The most significant political act by voters occurs one day every four years, when the greatest number turn out to pick the president.  They choose based on repeated impressions they have received from political advertising, much of it negative about another candidate.   Unlimited campaign funding leads to more heat, not more light.

The vote for president is a blank check to a person in whom they have more confidence or who promises to pursue a specific issue in line with the voter’s views.  Voters know neither if a candidate will perform in line with expectations nor the challenges they will face if elected.   Charisma counts.

The influence of any voter is reduced by the sheer size of the country.  While the electoral voting system artificially prevents a single national popular vote, the Electoral College distorts the weight of each vote in favor of voters in smaller states. 

Asking a vast nation of 349 million people to make a single, considered decision is not realistic and weighting each vote differently yields a system that is only imperfectly democratic.   Real direct democracy only works in small places like Switzerland or New England towns.

The lack of term limits and unlimited political spending work against popular control.  Democracy is reduced to the mere act of voting.   Some politicians even try to make voting more difficult.

In electing members of the House and Senate, votes are influenced by how well incumbents have done to bring federal funding home to the state.  Incumbents get campaign financial support from groups they have favored in Congress.  Their offices can serve to keep their names in front of the public. 

Most incumbents tend to hold onto their seats by using their inherent advantages and because politically pure districts have been created to help them. The net result of congressional elections is determined by only a handful of districts. 

The constitutional plan to keep the federal government from getting too far away from popular control is the idea of checks and balances.  But when, as now, a regal president enjoys a subservient Congress of his own party and a compliant Supreme Court, the plan fails.

A method exists that can counteract the gradual erosion of what might be called “the democratic method.”  It would require only one quick reflex by some of the voters.  It would occur in congressional elections, especially at the midterms.

If voters chose to split their votes between parties to ensure that the president and Congress were under different control, democracy would work better.  That may seem like a pipedream, but it is the most feasible way of forcing political compromise and a government that can produce results.  The alternative is what we have – partisan division and excessive presidential power.

Midterm elections could serve this purpose.  Better yet, even in presidential election years, voters could split their ballots to limit the winner’s free hand.

In short, split-ticket voting may be what saves democracy. 

This year’s midterms, only weeks away, are a test case.  As usual, the Democrats should pick up a few seats.   But given Trump’s distinctive and highly controversial way of governing, the midterm elections are likely to provide the opportunity to reconsider the 2024 presidential election.  Seldom is the question posed as sharply as it is now.

Trump had promised change from President Biden’s deeply unpopular immigration and economic policies.  He claims to keep his promises and many voters thought he would.  But Trump has disappointed them, scoring negative ratings in almost every major policy area.

Congressional Republicans have grown willing to risk the president’s retaliation as they face rejection by discontented voters.  Trying to save his domination, Trump’s GOP redistricted states and poured on the campaign cash.   He has sought to treat the election as a normal exercise, with traditional GOP support, allowing him to survive with unchecked authority.

But Trump harmed the consumer economy, caused an unwanted war, openly enriched himself, and failed to keep his promises.  In response, voters might regain their democratic power to do what Congress and the Supreme Court wouldn’t – restore checks and balances.

  

Sunday, September 27, 2026

What happens on November 4? The morning after

 

What happens on November 4?

Getting to ‘go’ – again

 

Gordon L. Weil

November 3 could be a big day.   The pundits and pollsters binge on forecasts about the Election Day verdict on President Trump and its implications.

Before the country gets to the election, it must go through the attacks on the electoral system itself.  They create a battleground and by the time the votes are counted, they may turn into a full-scale political war.

Trump believes that he and the GOP are favored by limiting voter participation.  Based on the premise that making voting more complicated discourages and deters Democrats more than Republicans, he exploits phony charges of past and potential voter fraud.  While fraud should be stopped, there’s almost no evidence of it having occurred.

While the courts prevent him from drastically reducing voting by mail, his forces have geared up to challenge any aspect of an election lost by the Trump GOP.  The rule seems to be: “if you can’t win it, mess it up.”  The Democrats have to organize to fight disputes that may extend well after Election Day.

If and when the votes are finally counted, there are three possible outcomes.   Each would have a major impact on the final two years of Trump’s term.

The Republicans could retain control of both the House and Senate.  Holding a closely divided House after a mid-term election would be highly unusual.  Such an outcome would be interpreted as a surprising and massive endorsement of Trump, even if the GOP majorities were tiny.

At that point, Trump might reasonably expect his party to continue its abandonment of most of its legislative responsibility in favor of his legislating by executive order.   In short, the motto for the second half of his term could be “more of the same.”  In fact, he could be encouraged to topple even more political norms.

But there may be some Republicans who are less accommodating.   As a lame duck, he may be less able to successfully back opponents over disloyal Republicans.  Constituent interests might take precedence over loyalty to him.  Or his lagging popularity might allow some defections.  In short, even a big win might limit, not boost, his authority in the GOP.

With the Republicans controlling both houses, the Democrats would have little more than the power of the podium.  Anti-Trumpism based on his defects is not enough.  They would have to build a case for 2028. They would need to develop alternatives to Trump’s moves, and not merely attack him. 

The ambition of the many Democratic progressives could get in the way of such a unified program.  They could seek to assert a special claim to leadership, if the Democrats were to fail completely in November.

The second probably more likely outcome would be the Democrats taking the House, while the GOP holds onto the Senate.  Stalemate would be likely, though the absence of agreement could open the way for Trump’s continued use of executive orders.  Or, given the fading role of a lame-duck president, they might try to find ways of compromising at least occasionally.

The possibility for compromise will depend on the four leaders.  Any of the current leaders might be replaced, making their attitude toward compromise a factor in their selection.  The choice of leaders, coming soon after the elections, could set the tone for the entire Congress.

Straight bipartisanship would be impossible.  But total war could be replaced by the leaders identifying issues on which a negotiated result would work better for both parties than deadlock.  Such agreement would benefit members wanting to show they can work across the aisle, while remaining solid partisans.

In the less likely outcome that the Democrats won control of the Senate, they could block all Trump nominations, especially to the courts and prevent the majority-vote passage of spending bills.  Their role could some make House compromises necessary to get anything done.

Finally, the Democrats could control both houses as the result of a Blue Wave, a sweeping Democratic victory.  This would be seen as a total rejection of Trump’s handling of all issues.  But it would not allow the Democrats to direct national policy.

Trump would face the choice between seeking a constructive relationship with the Democrats or escalating his all-out war.  His impressive ego could stand in the way of his making any deal for which he could not get all the credit.  Alternatively, he would need to find effective legislative liaison.

Trump reportedly fears a third impeachment.  If the House impeached him, the case would be tried before a Democratic Senate, and it would not be quickly dismissed as has been the case when the GOP controlled the Senate.  But it would be highly unlikely to succeed.

Whatever happens on Election Day, the presidential campaign begins the next day.  The congressional result may soon fade, eclipsed by the race for the White House.

 

 

 

 


Friday, September 11, 2026

Independent politics are coming; Democrats drop out

 

Independent politics are coming

Democrats drop out


Gordon L. Weil

 

Conventional wisdom tells us that political parties are fading away.   

The Republican Party has morphed into Trump’s personal property.  He is the RINO, but he counts.

The Democrats are divided, as usual, this time between traditional New Dealers and progressives, including the Social Democrats.

The deep discord between the two parties has turned compromise into a dirty word and made name calling and falsehood the standard.  Core partisans exist on each side, though many voters supposedly want constructive cooperation to solve practical problems.

The media promotes this picture, helping make it seem true.  But that’s not quite right.

Traditional conservative Republicans survive, but they may detest Trump.  Democrats may find unity in their shared rejection of Trump.  The existence of a moderate middle may be more myth than reality.  With Trump having become the single issue, compromise is impossible. 

The partisan division is real.  The GOP developed effective party discipline, and the normally unruly Democrats have finally reacted and become more disciplined.  In Congress, each side almost always follows the directives of its leaders.

Each party’s supporters include strong backers and leaners.  Moderates exist among the leaners, but not independents.  Only a small share of voters doesn’t lean in either direction and includes true independents who may determine election outcomes.

The media has so significantly become engaged in covering the political split that its coverage and opinions regard independents as political deviants rather than proponents of alternatives to division.  That’s how the party leaders see it as well.  Still, there are true independents.

Few members of the House and Senate slip party discipline.  The five biggest House dissenters are four Democrats, including Maine’s Jared Goldin, from districts that Trump won, and one Republican from a district that Harris carried.  In the Senate, Susan Collins (R-ME) and John Fetterman (D-PA) represent states won by the other party’s presidential candidate.

Two GOP senators who are leaving the Senate, have become willing to oppose Trump.  One of them, Texas Sen. John Cornyn, and Kentucky GOP Rep. Thomas Massie, a libertarian dissenter, became Trump victims and lost their primaries.  That’s proof that Trump’s power has suppressed independence. 

Sometimes, senators march to their own tune.  Kentucky GOP Sen. Rand Paul is a loyal libertarian. The two New Hampshire Democrats (one is not seeking reelection) sometimes are more responsive to their swing state more than to the party’s demands.  In 2010, the Alaska GOP dumped Sen. Lisa Murkowski, the leading Republican dissenter, but she won by write-ins. 

Some commentators suggest that the only way out of stalemate is the formation of a new party, a home for moderates from both sides.  Theoretically, Republican moderates opposed to Trump wouldn’t become Democrats, but could align with Democratic centrists.   Presumably, the GOP would melt away after Trump. 

While new parties have emerged and gained major party status, it’s rare, and there are no signs of it happening now.

Long ago in Maine, some Republicans in a then solidly red state decided to back Democrat Edmund Muskie for governor.  They did not become Democrats but chose to consider themselves as independents, and Muskie won.  That kind of choice may be happening in some of this year’s elections, and Democrats are trying to help it along. 

In Nebraska, independent Dan Osborn lost in 2024 after running a solid Senate race and is again opposing an incumbent Republican.  Democratic nominee Cindy Burbank has withdrawn from the race to improve his chances.

In South Dakota, independent Brian Bengs, formerly a Democrat, is running.  Democratic candidate Julian Beaudion dropped out.

In Idaho, independent Tod Achilles, a former Democrat, is running against an incumbent.  Democrat David Roth withdrew.

In Montana, independent Seth Bodnar is running with the support of Democratic leaders.  Alani Bankhead, the Democratic nominee, resisted pressure to withdraw, and she may help the GOP.

In Alaska, Democratic House candidate Matt Schultz dropped out in favor of independent Bill Hill.  Under the state’s unusual voting process, the top four open primary candidates for the Senate are on the ballot.  The fourth, a Democrat, dropped out, allowing a Republican to move up.  The result pits three Republicans against a single Democrat, already the frontrunner.

The Democrats’ tactic of strategic withdrawal is an answer to how to create a comfortable political space for Republicans who reject Trump’s takeover of their party without undergoing a political transformation.   It also reflects broad voter disappointment with both parties.

If the strategy works, it could give Democratic leaders heartburn just as Fetterman and Golden have done.  Independents may support Democratic leadership, but their party loyalty is not guaranteed.  If there are independent winners this year, they may not abandon their special status at the Capitol doorstep.

If the Democrats’ strategic withdrawal doesn’t work, it might not be taken as a failure, but rather as a first step. 


Sunday, August 30, 2026

Blue Wave may be coming

 

Blue Wave: wholesale or retail elections

‘All politics is local’ no longer true

Gordon L. Weil

This year’s election may reveal the difference between retail and wholesale politics.

The Republicans and many pundits see the congressional elections as hundreds of individual contests.  For most of them, picking a winner is easy, because voting traditionally hews to a single party.  The balance of power in Congress can be determined by a few swing elections, where there’s usually only a small gap between the two major candidates.

The GOP is increasingly worried about becoming a minority party.  They would be endangered if Democrats could add to their blue-collar and Black support with more women and, thanks to immigration, Hispanic voters.  Republicans have made inroads among union members and other blue-collar workers, but they are not expected to equal the Democratic gains.

Republicans look for ways to suppress voting among those voters seen as likely to support Democrats.  Their arsenal includes difficult identification requirements, shorter voting periods, reduced mail ballots and House redistricting to maximize the chances for their candidates to win.

However spurious his claims might be, Donald Trump’s assertion that his 2020 election had been fraudulently stolen, is used as justification for most voter suppression, which claims to help eliminate fraud.  For added GOP security, he pushed for congressional redistricting years before it is required by the Constitution and laws.

The president’s party often loses seats in the midterm election, and premature redistricting is meant to nullify that shift.  Redistricting for political purposes was explicitly approved by the Supreme Court.  The Democrats tried to match the GOP slicing-and-dicing moves, but have come up short.

The object of all these moves is to retain Republican majorities, no matter how thin, in the House and Senate.  That would not only help Trump continue to adopt policies by executive order without congressional oversight, but also to protect him from what he sees as an inevitable third impeachment if the Democrats gain control of the House.

Taken together, all of these moves constitute a retail approach to the elections.  The goal is to win just enough states and districts to hold onto control of both houses.  Most analysts have bought this approach, because it’s familiar. 

“All politics is local,” said the late House Speaker Tip O’Neill.  If retail politics prevail this year, then O’Neill’s wisdom prevails.  But Donald Trump has radically changed American politics and, if he is becoming the predominant issue in any congressional race, then the old sage can be proven wrong.

All serious polls show that Trump’s rating on every major policy is solidly negative.  Despite having almost unchecked power, he hasn’t delivered on key promises.  Even worse, he continues to promise success, but many people are losing confidence.  For example, he repeatedly announces that the unpopular Iran war is nearing an end, but it isn’t.  Then, he escalates it.

He promised no long wars, instantly lower consumer prices, deporting unlawful immigrants with criminal records and ending any special breaks for women and minorities.  He delivered a prolonged Iran war, higher prices, deportation of long-term immigrants leading productive lives and open discrimination against women and minorities, especially in military leadership.

In his second term, Trump has adopted or approved policies harmful to African Americans, women, farmers, Hispanic people, science and education.  While his policies may not create new Democrats, some of their members could vote for them as alternatives to his Republican enablers or simply not vote.  A relative few could tip many balances.

Trump relies on personal loyalty and keeps his core support.  Voter suppression and expected massive fraud claims where GOP candidates lose could help him.  By making the Democrats appear dangerous, he would frighten voters away from them.

Will Trump’s falling approval translate into enough Democratic votes for them to take Congress?  When the campaign began, few gave the Democrats a chance of taking Senate control.   Now nine Senate seats are in question.  This shift suggests that the Trump Republicans’ congressional control of the Senate is now in question.  The Democrats have a good chance in the House.

But will the success of Democratic Socialists in some primaries scare enough voters nationally to allow a clear path for Republicans?  The media promotes a possibly exaggerated struggle between the party’s progressives and moderates, but they could appear united in their opposition to Trump.

The Democrats make Trump the issue (wholesale); the Republicans make individual Democrat’s shortcomings the issue (retail).  Trump’s impulsive moves create political opportunities.  The Democrats’ infighting and inability to create a unified agenda do the same.

If the Democrats succeed, the result would be the Blue Wave.  It would extend the usual midterm congressional losses into a major rejection of Trump’s presidency.  If the Iran war continues and prices remain high, chances for a Blue Wave increase.  Trump probably knows that and has about two months to complete his defenses.

 

 

 

 


Friday, August 21, 2026

Election key: Trump turnout

 

Election key: Trump turnout

War over ballots


Gordon L. Weil

A single factor may be the key to the outcome of the midterm elections – turnout.

President Trump gets it.  He gives signs of believing that it’s better for his Republicans if fewer people vote. 

In the 2020 presidential election, he lost by 7 million votes out of the 156 million between the two main candidates.  Four years later, he won by over 2 million votes out of about 153 million.  The Democrats shed over 6 million votes.

He asserts that he won in 2020 and could conclude that a lower turnout favors Republicans.  Because most Republicans vote at the polling places on Election Day, while most Democrats prefer early voting, often by mail, that might have led him to oppose mail voting.

Republicans want to tighten access to voting.  They say they are combating election fraud though there’s little demonstrated evidence of it.  But Trump claims his loss resulted from widespread fraud.  Massive efforts to prove that point totally failed, but the claims persist and accepting them is a required mark of loyalty to Trump.

Voter fraud is a myth. While there may be rare problems, they are so minor that they cannot influence the results.  But donning the cloak of protecting democracy, the GOP can seem to be the good guys while preventing many Democrats from participating.

The Republicans try to limit voting access and question vote tabulation (only when they lose).  Making voting access more difficult, the GOP expects to deter lower income workers and the poor from making what could be a big effort to register and vote in person.  They also try to influence how votes are counted, which aims at throwing out Democratic ballots.

Trump is currently thinking about declaring a national emergency giving him the power to reduce or eliminate mail voting and to impose strict identification rules to screen out lower income and less educated voters who won’t have time or transport necessary to collect needed paperwork.  Reducing mail voting could get some help from the Postal Service.

He has fought hard to secure passage of the SAVE act that could allow him to accomplish his goals, but Congress won’t pass his bill.  Declaring a national emergency would be a shortcut, though it would be challenged.

This year, increased turnouts for midterm primaries encourage uncertain expectations of a big November turnout.  In Texas, for example, the 2.3 million Democratic votes compared with 2.2 million Republicans ballots.  Both the turnouts and the Democratic showing were unusually high, but three-quarters of eligible voters did not participate.

In November, Republicans who are disappointed with Trump could stay away.  But if the Democrats are thought to be leftwing extremists, GOP voters are unlikely to swing to their side.  That’s why there’s so much handwringing by pundits when a Democratic Socialist wins a primary.

But, even merely by staying away, a lower GOP turnout could help the Democrats. And it’s possible that high prices caused by the Iran War and uneasiness about immigration enforcement could cause some to protest by voting for Democrats.  Turnout will depend heavily on whether the elections are a referendum on Trump.

In practice, the question is whether voter suppression will work and if so, whether it will have a partisan effect. The GOP may believe that educated, affluent people will vote and remain reliable Republicans.

But, despite the focus on the Democrats losing the blue-collar vote, they are making major inroads among what once was a solid GOP vote. If women, affluent, and better educated people continue moving toward the Democrats and show up at the polls, they could upset the GOP strategy.

If Trump aims to make it easier for those groups to dominate the electorate, he may have missed that they are moving away from the GOP.  If he believes less educated voters are increasingly Republican, he may have erred in making voting access more difficult for them.  Plus, their share of the electorate is declining, while the more affluent Republicans are defecting.

In both parties, campaigns could boil down to GOTV – get out the vote.

Rarely does an issue affect turnout to the point it can determine the election outcome.  But consumer price hikes could cause results that go well beyond partisanship.  Prices rose under Biden, and Trump won by promising to reverse them quickly.  The Iran war made the situation worse, but he tells voters that small gas price increases are worth it.

Whatever politicians claim, consumer price increases have not been small.  When gasoline shoots up more than one dollar a gallon, it can fuel the kind of turnout that flips the Congress. 

Talk of a Blue Wave, a massive Democratic win, has begun to pass the straight-face test. But it may take a Blue Wave to drown the voter suppression that Trump seeks.

 

 

 

 

Sunday, April 5, 2026

Trump's last gasp?


Trump’s last gasp?

Helping MAGA survive

 

Gordon L. Weil

Donald Trump believes that he is exceptionally qualified to carry out a mandate to reshape America according to his own vision.

Above all, this mandate allows him to exercise personal and virtually absolute control, not only over the federal government, but over a myriad of aspects of national life.  Accomplishing his mandate, he could fulfill his claim to be the GOAT – the greatest of all time.

He runs the risk that original constitutional processes will frustrate his mandate.  The most basic are the elections that choose the president and Congress.  He devotes much attention to undermining elections with false fraud claims and attempts to suppress voting, but he cannot erase them.

As the congressional election year grinds on, threatening at least the GOP House majority, he is compelled to make an extreme effort to achieve his goals.  The elections might produce a Democratic majority that could thwart his hopes.  Or they could produce Republican victory, reaffirming his vision.

He must achieve his MAGA ambitions quickly.  If he faces rejection, and this is his last gasp in November, he must accomplish all he can now.   If the voters approve of his efforts, his two lame duck years will be transformed to give him the third term powers he has coveted.  Either way, between now and November 3, the public can expect his all-out effort to achieve his goals.

While observers focus on the Iran war’s impact on affordability and foreign relations, Trump may see winning the war and destroying as much as possible of Iran’s dangerous regime as being key to an eventual recognition of his greatness in dismantling a potential nuclear threat.  That may be why he presses on.

In misunderstanding NATO, he may be forcing the alliance to update itself.  Europe will be better able to defend itself, becoming more independent of the U.S.  Trump assigns himself credit for inducing the Europeans to play a bigger role; he lauds himself for military budget increases among America’s allies.  He scorns allies for not doing his bidding and now targets NATO.

Trump obviously sees the armed forces as a major tool in exploiting American power to bring change to the world and the use of the threat of war as a believable and acceptable policy.  His easy but limited success in Venezuela has obviously been intoxicating and encourages him to try to duplicate it.   Cuba is a tempting target, and he will press on in seeking others.

In the process, he and Pete Hegseth, his amazing and alarming choice to lead the armed forces, reshapes the military.  Without regard to morale and readiness, they are stripping high command of women and African Americans. Hegseth believes such people are promoted simply because of their sex or race, and will continue to pursue military ethnic cleansing until yearend.

Trump sees federal judges as political, not judicial, officials.  He reflexively attributes his court defeats to liberal judges.  If Congress flips in November, he will not be able to put his backers on the bench.  Thus, it reasonable to expect a rush to get his nominees confirmed before the elections. 

Executive orders, questionable legislating by the executive, will continue to cascade. Trump can be expected to kill as much regulation that remains as possible, especially any surviving elements of environmental or financial protection.  As needed, he will tighten his control of supposedly independent boards.

While U.S. dependence on certain imports could moderate his tariff policy somewhat, he seems determined to press ahead with it.  He uses tariffs in the same way as he deploys military forces, as a demonstration of the America power at his disposal.  In both cases, his preoccupation with power obscures the ability to appreciate unintended consequences.

Trump’s unyielding pursuit of his agenda is bringing two reactions that increasingly call his insistence into question.

Europe, Canada, Australia and others are becoming increasingly critical and more independent of the U.S., which was accustomed to working with allies, even if it had the greatest force.   When Trump says the U.S. can go it alone, he pushes other countries into new relationships and reducing ties with it.  American power decreases, opening opportunities for China. 

The other factor is the gradual erosion of his support among some congressional Republicans.   Trump has taken over many congressional powers with GOP majority backing.   Despite being responsible for their own loss of control, some members slip away from him and others leave Congress.  Democrats expect usual mid-term election gains and maybe more.

Congressional races have become national elections.  Because of Trump’s sweeping and bold actions and the relatively minor influence of Congress, the election unavoidably becomes a decision about him. 

Trump finds himself in a political spotlight of his own creation.  Win or lose, perhaps that’s what matters the most to him. 

Friday, December 19, 2025

Is Trump becoming desperate? Outllook for 2026


Gordon L. Weil

Running under the surface of all politics these days is next year’s battle for congressional control.  It will amount to a report card on President Trump, and it could set the terms for his administration’s final years and the 2028 presidential elections.

Trump knows that.   This week he made a televised address that sounded like a campaign speech.  He asked voters to withhold their judgment on his promises until they see the results next year.  Meanwhile, without the required congressional approval, he may make transition payments to taxpayers, beginning with a bonus to military personnel.

That he is desperate to turn around his falling poll ratings was evident from his false claims and extravagant promises.   For example, no reduction in drug prices could exceed 100 percent, but he promised more – “even 600 percent.”  His speech contained none of the bipartisan appeal of a traditional presidential address; it was pure Trump campaigning.

Can he hold onto the congressional control that gives him the ability to do almost anything he wants?   The 2026 elections hold the answer.

The Republican majority now hold a narrow and fluctuating majority in the House and a 53-47 majority in the Senate.  

The party of an incumbent president usually loses seats in midterm elections.   Since Franklin D. Roosevelt, only Bill Clinton and the second George Bush picked up seats.  Unlike Trump, they both enjoyed high popularity at the time. 

The Democrats should flip the House.   Trump believes GOP gerrymandering can produce new Republican seats to offset Democratic gains.  The Democrats have reacted by trying to redistrict in states they control.

Even if he is right, a GOP House majority might no longer give him unlimited power.   MAGA loyalists dislike his changing positions on releasing the Epstein files, and his foreign moves.  The obviously limited role allowed House GOP women is also beginning to cause problems.  MAGA members have begun to defy Speaker Mike Johnson, on whom he relies.  

The Senate is not subject to redistricting.  The GOP may now feel safe, but history shows that, like the House, Senate midterm races are influenced by the president’s popularity.  

The election results yield several possible scenarios.

The third term scenario.  Republicans retain control of both houses and act as if Trumpism would roll on in 2028.  Fearful of his ability to defeat them in primaries, GOP members continue to allow him broad powers.

The lame duck scenario.  No matter which party controls one or both houses, Trump’s influence fades.  Members look forward to no longer having him at the top of the ticket, and being forced to run on their own records.

The Democrats would try to create issues for 2028, as they have with healthcare assistance.     If they control the House, they would have an enhanced forum to make their case.

Stalemate scenario.  If the Democrats win the House, they will be able to block at least some of the president’s proposals.  If Trump holds fast to his treatment of the Democrats as “the enemy,” the government could be deadlocked.   The 2028 presidential campaign becomes the sole focus.

If the Democrats win the Senate, it could mean political war.  They could block Trump’s nominees to the courts and executive agencies.  While his veto would limit their chances to dictate their own policies, his power would be substantially reduced.  His eyes on the Prize, he would concentrate on foreign affairs, where congressional power is limited.

Compromise scenario.  If the Democrats were to control either or both houses, Trump could decide to try to make deals with them, in line with political tradition.   His concern with his legacy is greater than his commitment to GOP conservatism.  He wants to be seen positively and hailed for great achievements, so compromise could yield more for him than conflict.

That could explain his surprisingly friendly encounter with Zohran Mamdani, the newly elected New York city mayor.  He was friendly to Mamdani, making many MAGA backers nervous.    Just as an aging President Biden faded from the scene, Trump could compensate for his aging by being less combative.

The Democrats’ burden would then face the choice of either cooperating, which the polls say people want, or seeking partisan redlines as a way of striking a clear contrast with Trump and undermining 2028 Trumpism. 

The media focus is now on gerrymandering and the contest to redraw House maps, but the real 2026 contest may be about whether Trump has retained enough popularity to carry on.   Or is the electorate returning to more traditional GOP conservatism and regaining some confidence in the Democrats?  

Mere opposition to Trump is not enough as the Democratic platform.  While they may not achieve total unity, the Democrats need better leadership and to offer practical alternatives with bipartisan appeal if they want to stage a comeback next year.  

  

Friday, July 11, 2025

Third party alternatives coming for 2026 elections

 

Gordon L. Weil

In the political off season, if that still exists, people often turn to dreams of a new party.  As soon as any frustrated player talks about forming a new political party, they are scolded for not recognizing how difficult it is and that new parties don’t work. 

Now comes Elon Musk, whose foreign birth would deny him the presidency, but who wants to create the America Party.  

Ignore him, and maybe he’ll go away.  Maybe not.  Maybe he is sending a message.  He is not proposing a “third” party.  That’s because there are no political parties left standing.

The traditional Republican Party no longer exists.  It was seized by Donald Trump, who is Republican in Name Only.  The remnants of the former Republican establishment are defeated and dispersed. The vote on the One Big Beautiful Bill is prime evidence of the Trump monolith overriding traditional GOP concerns about the debt.

“I am not a member of any organized political party. I’m a Democrat,” said cowboy philosopher Will Rogers.  The party has no program, other than opposing Trump, no leader, and no unity.  It governs a minority of states, which may matter little in the face of Trump authoritarian rule.

The Democrats’ progressive wing wants to move the party toward a larger role for government and higher taxes on the wealthy with the funds being used for social policies.  Traditional Democrats are more conservative, competing with the GOP more effectively, they say, for blue collar voters.  

The problem with the Democrats is that too many believe that being opposed to Trump is all it takes to win. 

Both major, but dying, parties fear what they see as a third party that could capture voters who would normally support one or the other of them.  In 1992, independent Ross Perot may have taken supporters away from both sides.  Having learned that lesson, each attacks new party advocates.

Many voters are discontent with what they see as the government’s failure to respond to their concerns about their economic condition and outlook.  They want change, which explains the successes of Barack Obama and Donald Trump. 

Trump provides change.  Instead of a hope, voters have the reality.  The talk of a third party reveals that some voters have found that, in their desire for change, they gave Trump a blank check.  Musk believes he has the formula and the funding to offer change without Trump.

But the third-party movement misses the point, especially when the strongest anti-Trump sentiment comes from extreme fiscal conservatives like Kentucky GOP Sen. Rand Paul and extreme liberals like Vermont Democratic Sen. Bernie Sanders.  There’s no third party that would accommodate both.

The answer is likely not a third national party but a series of alternatives.  The Trump opposition could be formed out of a combination of movements.  Different solutions could work among different electorates.

In the upcoming 2026 congressional elections, Musk’s party could field candidates in targeted districts.  Despite Musk’s maverick image, these candidates, holding views on trade and economic policy akin to traditional Republican conservatives, could either win seats, defeat Trumpers or hand districts to Democrats by splitting the GOP.

More independent candidates could run.  Maine makes the case.  It has elected two independent governors, one of whom now sits in the U.S. Senate.  That’s at least theoretically possible in 2026 with a strong independent now in the governor’s race.  In Nebraska, an independent candidate has a strong chance for a Senate seat.

The chief appeal of independents is not that they are moderate, taking a position between the two parties, but that they are not part of the parties.  Their independence, a willingness to find practical, non-ideological solutions, may represent an appealing version of change.

Another element of the alternative effort would be philanthropy.  The New York Times has reported about a group of foundations that will support opposition to authoritarian moves by the Trump administration.  While they are outside of the partisan process, their role provides indirect help to Trump’s opponents.

Private funding also supports efforts to get people to the polls. The Republican Party openly tries to discourage voter participation in the belief that marginal voters are likely to support Democrats.  Gerrymandering runs wild. To effectively oppose Trump, getting out the vote may be far more important than other actions, including a third party.

In next year’s congressional elections, the Democrats or at least an anti-Trump coalition ought to be able to take control of the House, now held by a tiny GOP majority.  Some Democratic unity would help.  If Trump’s authoritarianism has succeeded in creating widespread opposition, the real test would come in flipping GOP Senate seats.

Musk has a point.  At the same time, he misses the point.  A single, unified party is not the solution to Trumpism; an array of alternatives may be.